Payroll software vs payroll outsourcing in Singapore: Which is better?

Small business owners in Singapore often face the dilemma of whether to use payroll software or outsource their payroll. Both options have their pros and cons, but which is the better choice for your business? It ultimately depends on your business’ specific needs and circumstances. Read on to find out what are some of the key factors to consider so that you can make an informed decision!

What is payroll software?

A payroll software is a program or system that helps businesses manage and process employee payroll and taxes. This can include calculating wages, withholding the correct amount of taxes, and submitting payments to the government on behalf of the company.

Using payroll software can simplify payroll processes for both HR departments and employees, as it streamlines all payroll-related tasks into one streamlined system. Additionally, payroll software often provides other HR features such as leave management or shift scheduling, which helps to streamline and improve communication with employees.

Tip: Learn the benefits of using a payroll software and how to implement successfully in your company

What is payroll outsourcing?

Payroll outsourcing is the practice of hiring a third-party provider to manage payroll tasks for your business. This can include calculating wages, withholding taxes, and making payroll tax payments on behalf of the company.

With constantly changing regulations, outsourcing payroll can provide a peace of mind with improved compliance as these payroll specialists have the knowledge and expertise to stay updated on regulatory changes, reducing the risk of non-compliance and associated penalties.

Factors to consider when deciding between payroll outsourcing and payroll software

Both payroll outsourcing and payroll software have their own advantages and drawbacks. It is therefore important to consider the following factors before making a decision:

  1. What is your company’s size and growth potential?

Payroll software can offer a more convenient cost-effective solution for smaller businesses with a steady employee count. On the other hand, outsourcing payroll to a provider may offer the scalability and expertise needed to handle the increased workload for larger businesses or ones with complex payroll needs.

  1.  How much control and flexibility do you want in managing your payroll process?

With payroll software, you have the ability to customise to meet the specific needs of your business and make changes as needed.

Outsourcing gives you access to experts in payroll management, but may be less flexible, as you will be working with a third-party provider who may have their own processes and procedures in place.

  1. Does your in-house team have the time or expertise to manage payroll?

If you have a dedicated HR and payroll team, utilising software may be a more cost-effective solution.

However, If your team lacks the experience or time to accurately handle payroll tasks, outsourcing may be a better option as these payroll specialists have the knowledge and expertise to stay updated on regulatory changes, reducing the risk of non-compliance and associated penalties. Outsourcing can also help to free up time and resources for businesses to focus on their core competencies.

Tip: Learn what are the top 5 HR tasks and how to automate them to reduce HR risks

  1. Do you need more help in managing your HR matters besides payroll processing?

Payroll software typically offers a wide range of features besides payroll processing, such as leave management, claims management, time tracking, and shift scheduling.

The outsourced payroll provider may not be able to provide all these services such as shift scheduling or leave approvals, given that these tend to require more timely attention as they impact the daily operations.

  1. Are you planning to stay local or expand regionally?

It is important to consider the specific needs and regulations of the region in which you operate.  Payroll processes can vary greatly from country to country, and choosing a solution that does not comply with regional laws and regulations could result in penalties for your business. 

For example, in some countries there may be mandatory contributions to social security or pension funds that must be made on behalf of employees. In others, there may be specific rules regarding payroll taxes and deductions. 

An experienced payroll outsourcing provider will have an in-depth understanding of regional payroll needs and requirements, ensuring compliance and avoiding potential penalties. Alternatively, if you choose to use payroll software, it is important to ensure that it is equipped to handle the specific needs of the regions that you are operating in.

Overall, there is no one-size-fits-all solution for payroll management. It's important to continuously reassess and adapt as your business grows and changes.

Can I choose both payroll outsourcing and payroll software?

Yes, it is possible to use both payroll outsourcing and payroll software for your business! Some companies choose to outsource their payroll processes but also utilise software to manage certain HR matters such as leave approvals, expense management and shift scheduling. Ultimately, it is up to your specific needs and preferences as a business owner. 

Some advantages of using both options include having access to expert outsourced payroll professionals as well as the convenience and efficiency of automated software systems. However, it is important to carefully consider the cost-benefit analysis and ensure that both options integrate smoothly for your company's unique payroll and HR requirements. Overall, using a combination of outsourcing and software can be a great solution for effectively managing employee payroll and other HR matters.

If you are looking for payroll software…

Payboy is a Payroll and HR Management Software which automates the essential HR processes through a seamless ecosystem, so that businesses can focus on the HR work that truly matters– bringing out the best in their people.

Being business owners ourselves, we understand the little intricacies and problems fellow SMEs face. We are therefore always finding ways to improve and simplify our processes. Simple, nice, and easy to use. That’s our ethos. And as we use our own product, we’re rediscovering and evaluating it on the daily. 

Do it all with our flexible selection of modules to tailor a solution that solves the unique challenges faced by your business:

1. Payroll processing

2. Leave management

3. Claims management 

4. Applicant tracking

5. Time attendance

6. Shift Scheduling

7. Appraisal system

8. Inventory management

9. Project costing

10. Training Management

11. Benefits

Is Payboy HR & Payroll software eligible under PSG Grant?

Payboy is also eligible under the PSG Grant! You can find our answers to your questions regarding PSG grant here. When there are businesses, there will be Payboy. Sign up for a demo below if you are keen to find out more!

Find out how you can do it all with Payboy

Reach out to us if you are keen for a free demo on how we can help you save hours and give you some peace of mind on payroll and other HR matters so that you can focus on your business and people.
here are some other news you might like:
crossmenuarrow-right